As outlined by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) this week, President Donald Trump’s plans to dramatically increase deportations are causing panic in immigrant communities around the country. The aggressive plans also should be panicking federal budget officials, who are going to have to figure out a way to pay for the big boost in personnel and infrastructure envisioned in two memos Homeland Security Secretary John Kelly issued Tuesday. They are likely to add billions of dollars to the tab for Trump’s immigration crackdown, on top of the $21 billion DHS officials have estimated it could cost to build the president’s desired wall on the border with Mexico.
Related: Homeland Security outlines tougher immigration measures
“If they do indeed want to do this by using DHS agents...they will have to get significantly more funding to accomplish this, or change the priorities within the DHS,” says Ben Gitis, director of labor market policy at the American Action Forum, a center-right economic think tank. Gitis wrote a report last year on what it would require to remove all of the 11 million-plus undocumented immigrants who are in the United States within two years, as Trump proposed during the campaign. The total cost: $400 billion to $600 billion.
The Trump administration isn’t proposing deportations on that scale in its latest guidelines, but it is suggesting a significant expansion in both the manpower dedicated to catching and detaining undocumented immigrants and the powers they have to send people out of the country. Among the big-ticket items in Kelly’s “implementation memoranda”—aimed at carrying out the executive order on immigration enforcement Trump signed in January—are hiring thousands more Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) and Border Patrol officers. Kelly wrote that he has “directed ICE to hire 10,000 officers and agents expeditiously, subject to available resources,” to carry out enforcement actions. That number is almost double the 5,700 deportation officers that ICE’s Enforcement and Removal Operations office currently employs. Kelly’s memo also calls for the Customs and Border Protection department to begin hiring 5,000 more Border Patrol agents; the department currently employs about 21,000 agents.
Last year’s Homeland Security budget request gives a hint at how much that will cost: In the Obama administration’s fiscal 2017 budget request, DHS asked for $6.6 million to hire 100 additional officers “to support ICE in apprehending and removing priority alien targets.” Multiply that price tag by 100, and the department is looking at a sum of $660 million to pay for the 10,000 additional enforcement officers it wants to hire. DHS asked for $3.8 billion, meanwhile, to pay for Border Patrol’s “operational staffing” budget for 21,000 agents. Based on that figure, adding another 5,000 agents would cost another roughly $900 million.
And those sums don’t cover all of the staffing increases Kelly outlined. His memos also request 500 more Air and Marine border agents; a yet-to-be-determined increase in the number of asylum and fraud detection officers posted at detention facilities near the Mexican border; and a “surge” in hiring of immigration judges and asylum officers at the Department of Justice to evaluate immigration cases. Depending on how many additional people the government hires for those roles, it could cost hundreds of millions of dollars more.
Gitis also points out that the Kelly memos don’t account for the strain this enforcement surge could put on local police officers. “Most apprehensions currently happen with local police officers,” Gitis says. Kelly writes that the DHS in this new deportation effort wants to “maximize participation by state and local jurisdictions.” With limited time and resources, that could push local police forces to shift priorities away from other efforts.
U.S. Homeland Security Secretary John Kelly waves as he arrives to meet Guatemala's president, Jimmy Morales, at the Presidential Palace, in Guatemala City, February 22. Kelly issued a set of memos earlier in the week detailing an aggressive immigration enforcement plan. Luis Echeverria/REUTERS
Holding all of the immigrants that ICE and Border Patrol agents round up could also prove pricey. The Kelly memos direct ICE and Customs and Border Protection to “allocate all available resources to expand their detention capabilities and capacities at or near the border with Mexico to the greatest extent practicable.” But current detention centers—mostly old jails that have been repurposed and run by private contractors—are already over the 34,000 detention bed quota set by Congress. The Wall Street Journal reported in October that ICE was holding more than 40,000 people. Signing contracts with more private prison operators would not be cheap. The 2014 contract the Obama administration signed with Corrections Corporation of America to run a facility in Dilley, Texas to house the flood of Central American families crossing the border cost $1 billion over four years.
DHS estimated in its fiscal 2017 budget request that each adult housed at one of these immigrant detention centers costs an average of $126.46 per day. Immigrants in detention are currently held for an average of about 30 days. Kelly’s memo, however, emphasizes the need to expand short-term detention. And according to Phil Wolgin, managing director of the immigration policy team at liberal think tank Center for American Progress, several policy changes outlined in the memo will make it easier for the government to deport people rapidly.
Among other things, DHS is expanding who is eligible for what’s called “expedited removal,” where an undocumented immigrant can be sent out of the country without ever seeing a judge.
“Under current policy…expedited removal could only be used for people who were apprehended within 100 miles of the border and within 14 days of entering the country,” explains Wolgin. But the new memos say that removal process can now apply to anyone “who cannot prove they have not been in the U.S. continuously for two years,” he says. That gives the Trump administration a way to reduce some of the most costly issues, like holding thousands of people in detention centers for weeks on end.
It doesn’t, however, erase the costs of transporting people back to their countries of origin, Wolgin notes. Only about half of the undocumented immigrants currently in the country are from Mexico, according to the Pew Research Center. That means roughly half of the undocumented immigrants the government sweeps up would have to be flown back to their countries on charter flights. In a 2015 report, Gitis estimated it would cost more than $11 billion to transport all of the undocumented immigrants who did not return home on their own. Based on Gitis’s cost estimates, even transporting 1 million of those people back to their countries of origin would cost more than $1 billion.
Trump will lay out in more detail what he plans to spend on immigration enforcement in the coming year in his annual budget, which the White House says will be released in mid-March. He is also expected to go over some of these questions during his address to Congress next week. But proposing costly new programs and actually getting them funded are two different things. Republicans in Congress may be eager to prove they are tough on immigration, but fiscal conservatives, particularly in the House, are also unlikely to approve blowing up the federal budget to pay for these types of measures. Adding billions of dollars to the Homeland Security budget to deport undocumented immigrants is bound to start a fight—both with spendthrift Republicans and with Democrats, who object on social and moral grounds.
Wolgin says budget limitations aren’t all that reassuring to the immigrants fearful of being deported, however. “Even if they don’t get the money,” he says, “it does seem like they are going to do everything they can to ramp up enforcement.”Try Newsweek: Subscription offers